GEICO and Progressive Continue to Lead the U.S. Auto Insurance Market

GEICO and Progressive | May 04, 2020

  • GEICO and Progressive snagged nearly 92% of all premium growth last year, according to a new study by J.D. Power.

  • GEICO ranked the highest among large auto insurers with a score of 867 out of a possible 1,000.

  • The Hartford ranked the highest among mid-sized auto insurers with a score of 895.

Just two insurance carriers – GEICO and Progressive – snagged nearly 92% of all premium growth last year, according to a new study by J.D. Power. The result seems to cement a trend toward increased adoption of direct-to-consumer auto insurance that’s been building for years – and is likely to grow even more in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
 

Over the past decade, auto insurance costs have risen at two times the rate of inflation, that’s consuming a larger share of discretionary income and playing an increasingly significant role in household finances. Add the effects of record-high levels of unemployment and the 52% of auto insurance customers who say they plan to either reduce coverage, shop for another carrier or switch to another carrier because of COVID-19, and the outcome for the industry is clear: price is going to be a bigger factor. Direct insurers are in the best position right now to benefit from this trend due to their cost-of-acquisition advantages, but there’s more to acquiring – and retaining – customers than price alone. Customers who have a poor experience are eight times more likely to shop than those who do not, and brand perception remains critical.

- Tom Super, head of property and casualty insurance at J.D. Power.


Read more: PROGRESSIVE TO OFFER $1 BILLION IN REBATES TO AUTO INSURANCE CUSTOMERS


Other key findings of J.D. Power’s 2020 Insurance Shopping Study included:

  • There is little loyalty in the auto insurance market.

Prior to the COVID-19 outbreak, 77% of auto insurance customers were either actively shopping or experienced an adverse event – like poor customer service or a rate increase �� that triggered shopping. According to a J.D. Power survey conducted on April 14 – in the midst of the coronavirus outbreak – 52% of auto insurance customers said they planned to manage insurance costs by either reducing coverage, shopping for another carrier or switching carriers because of COVID-19.

  • Price continues to grow as a factor in customer satisfaction.

Price continues to grow as a factor in customer satisfaction. Since 2012, the price factor measured by J.D. Power’s study has increased by 54% as a key driver of satisfaction with the purchase experience. At the same time, the gap between overall satisfaction and price satisfaction has grown. Over the past decade, customers have generally become more satisfied with their insurers – in all areas except price.

  • Direct models are resonating with customers.

Direct carriers have several structural advantages that help them click with customers, according to J.D. Power. Lower commissions and administrative expenses give direct carriers a 10-percentage-point cost advantage over exclusive and independent agent carriers. Ninety per cent (90%) of customers say they are open to purchasing auto insurance online. Direct carriers have taken seven percentage points of market share from agent insurers over the past decade, and this year earned the highest scores in every factor of the purchase experience in J.D. Power’s study.

  • Poor customer experience destroys brand loyalty.

According to J.D. Power, the primary drivers that push customers to shop around are poor service experiences and price. Customers who are frustrated over price are five times more likely to shop around than those who aren’t. Customers who experience poor service are eight times more likely to shop.

GEICO ranked the highest among large auto insurers for providing a satisfying purchase experience, with a score of 867 out of a possible 1,000. Nationwide (862) ranked second, with State Farm (860) rounding out the top three.
 

Read more: TEXAS FARM BUREAU INSURANCE TO REFUND OVER $20 MILLION TO AUTO INSURANCE CUSTOMERS


The Hartford ranked the highest among mid-sized auto insurers with a score of 895. Erie Insurance ranked second with a score of 880 and American Family ranked third with a score of 878.
 

About GEICO

Government Employees Insurance Company. Puzzled, are you? Well, the name goes back to the beginnings of our company. Founder Leo Goodwin first targeted a customer base of U.S. government employees and military personnel. Today, of course, GEICO has grown to provide insurance to a wide range of customers. GEICO is built on ingenuity, perseverance, innovation, resilience, and hard, honest work. From its humble beginnings in the midst of the Great Depression to its current place as one of the most successful companies in the nation, GEICO represents a quintessential American success story.
 

About Progressive

For more than 80 years, Progressive has offered a wide range of insurance choices to customers, including Auto, Home, Renters, Commercial Auto, Small Business, Motorcycle, Boat policies, and more. Progressive is the third largest auto insurer in the country a combined effort of every single Progressive person. We’re a diverse group of more than 36,000 talented employees—from all walks of life, all fields of business, and all 50 states. Everyone here plays a role in our success as we continue to find new and better ways to move the insurance industry forward and be there for our customers during every stage of their lives.

Spotlight

Written by Sovos’ team of regulatory specialists, this guide for insurers provides everything you need to know about the IPT regulatory landscape.

A mix of deep dive country-by-country information in addition to guidance on IPT and the digital tax landscape, this guide is for any insurer wanting to know more about IPT compliance.

Despite its focus on Europe, our guide also explores other jurisdictions in Asia, Australia, North and South America. This guide is your trusted source of information wherever in the world you write business.

Spotlight

Written by Sovos’ team of regulatory specialists, this guide for insurers provides everything you need to know about the IPT regulatory landscape.

A mix of deep dive country-by-country information in addition to guidance on IPT and the digital tax landscape, this guide is for any insurer wanting to know more about IPT compliance.

Despite its focus on Europe, our guide also explores other jurisdictions in Asia, Australia, North and South America. This guide is your trusted source of information wherever in the world you write business.

Related News

CORE INSURANCE,INSURANCE TECHNOLOGY

Alera Group Acquires the Ascent Group for $3 Billion

Alera Group | January 05, 2023

Alera Group, a national insurance, wealth, and retirement plan services provider, has acquired The Ascent Group and allied firms. The deal adds $1.5 billion to Alera Group Wealth Services' RIA business and $1.3 billion to Alera Group Retirement Plan Services. The Summit Group in Virginia and Walsh & Nicholson Financial Group in Pennsylvania are connected to the Ascent Group. The Ascent Group has 42 employees, 15 of whom are financial advisors. By the end of 2022, Alera Group Wealth Services had $7.5 billion in assets, which included $1.5 billion in RIA assets and about $6 billion in AUM. One of the most fundamental components of the Ascent Group's investment infrastructure is the turnkey asset management program (TAMP), which was created to lower the overall client expenses by bringing crucial operations in-house and eliminating vendors. According to Alera Group, The Ascent Group is a good fit for the company's strategy of providing synergies and strategic benefits across its employee benefits and property and casualty verticals. It lets the company offer more complete solutions to clients, which can really help plan sponsors and participants come together. The organization is delighted to have the team join its expanding division in a role that will serve as a cornerstone. Meanwhile, the terms of the transaction were not disclosed. About Alera Group Alera Group serves thousands of clients, offering various services such as employee benefits, P&C, wealth, and retirement plans. It merged 24 dynamic US offices. The organization blends national experience and resources with local, tailored service. It is the nation's 7th largest privately-held employee benefits firm, 15th-largest independent insurance agency, and 16th-largest privately-held insurance firm.

Read More

CLAIMS, RISK MANAGEMENT

CCIG Acquires Cairn Advisors for Expansion

CCIG | February 21, 2023

On February 20, 2023, CCIG, a risk management and insurance solutions provider, announced its acquisition of Cairn Advisors, LLC, for business expansion. With the Texas-based firm Cairn Advisors, it expands its reach in Austin with expectations of 20% organic growth in 2023. With this acquisition, it opened its new office located in Austin in 2021. It will improve Cairn Advisors' client services and establish operations in its new office location. Even after the acquisition, co-founders of Cairn Advisors, Taylor Rogers and Rich Hejny, would continue to drive growth and provide employee benefits services in Texas. It would reflect CCIG's dedication to customer experiences. With a customized boutique approach, it would adhere to CCIG's aim of delivering the products and resources of a more prominent insurance firm. With extraordinary organic growth, CCIG is listed in the Top 100 Brokers of the United States. It is one of the fastest-growing private companies in the country. Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of America have constantly recognized it as the "Best Practices" Insurance Broker for nine years. It has also been rewarded with multiple Denver Top Workplace awards. Chief Operating Officer of CCIG, JB Richardson, said, "This acquisition enhances our ability to serve more clients across the Southwest region, underscoring our strategic expansion, with a focus on employee benefits." He added, "The Cairn Advisors team shares our passion for creating personalized, forward-thinking insurance solutions, and we are thrilled to leverage their expertise for our current and future clients." (Source – Cision PR Newswire) Co-founder of Cairn Advisors, Taylor Rogers, said, "We are thrilled to join the CCIG team as we continue to rapidly expand our employee benefits practice," Rogers said. "CCIG's curious approach aligns with our vision for how to best serve our clients. The culture aligns with what we believe is critical to building a great business and we look forward to a bright future together." (Source – Cision PR Newswire) About CCIG Headquartered in Englewood, Colorado, CCIG, an insurance company, provides solutions for personal and commercial insurance, risk and claims management, surety, employee benefits, home, auto, claims advocacy, risk management and claims analysis since 1985. It has been recognized as one of the top insurance brokerage providers for Property, Casualty, Risk Management, Benefits, Life and Wealth Management services across the United States. It offers customized and cost-effective solutions for business and personal insurance requirements for every company category, from international public trade companies to local family businesses. This customization assists in the management of exposures to risks.

Read More

CORE INSURANCE, RISK MANAGEMENT

Idelic Introduces Idelic Insurance Agency for Fleets

Idelic | January 19, 2023

Idelic Inc. recently announced the launch of Idelic Insurance Agency, LLC, a technology-driven managing general agent (MGA) aimed at providing commercial fleets with tailored insurance coverage. The insurance pricing will reflect the fleets’ risk improvement by using the Idelic Program, a comprehensive approach to improving driver safety and reducing crashes. Idelic Insurance Agency also aims to provide a modern approach to improving insurance outcomes by allowing fleets to use technology and processes to reduce losses. The insurance agency will price renewals based on the fleets’ successful adoption and results. The Idelic Program consists of two major components: Safety Suite® and Driver Safety Playbook. Safety Suite® is the best driver performance management platform in the trucking industry. It collects driver risk data and uses machine learning algorithms to identify high-risk drivers. Meanwhile, the Driver Safety Playbook is an excellent guide to engaging drivers, providing coaching and step-by-step professional development plans made by working with insurers and trucking's safest fleets. On average, fleets utilizing Idelic Program can witness a 20% decrease in preventable crashes in the first year. "Commercial auto fleet insurance is inherently complex with a multitude of nuances from fleet to fleet. The process of evaluating risks has traditionally relied on underwriter experience and judgment, but insurers are increasingly looking for a more data-driven way to evaluate risks. Idelic Insurance Agency will do just that," stated Michael Gramm, Senior Vice President of Insurance at Idelic Insurance Agency. "By working closely with fleets that choose to use the Idelic Program, we can better leverage critical driver behavior data to quote policies that reflect their reduced crash risk," he added. (Source – Business Wire) The Idelic Program and Idelic Insurance Agency are timely solutions to help fleets combat rising insurance rates and reduce losses significantly. However, fleet insurance costs and availability are once again among the Top 10 motor carrier executive concerns listed by American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI). About Idelic Inc. Pittsburgh-based Idelic is a software provider dedicated to delivering the best insurance outcomes for fleets. The Idelic Program combines process and technology in a tool designed for and proven successful among fleets and insurers alike. Additionally, the program uses predictive analytics to identify risky drivers and professional development plans to help change behavior patterns and provide insurers with evidence of long-term improvements in crash reduction to negotiate lower rates. The company's experienced technical and industry experts understand the trucking and insurance industries' needs and provide tailored solutions to clients' real problems.

Read More