GEICO and Progressive Continue to Lead the U.S. Auto Insurance Market

  • GEICO and Progressive snagged nearly 92% of all premium growth last year, according to a new study by J.D. Power.

  • GEICO ranked the highest among large auto insurers with a score of 867 out of a possible 1,000.

  • The Hartford ranked the highest among mid-sized auto insurers with a score of 895.

Just two insurance carriers – GEICO and Progressive – snagged nearly 92% of all premium growth last year, according to a new study by J.D. Power. The result seems to cement a trend toward increased adoption of direct-to-consumer auto insurance that’s been building for years – and is likely to grow even more in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
 

Over the past decade, auto insurance costs have risen at two times the rate of inflation, that’s consuming a larger share of discretionary income and playing an increasingly significant role in household finances. Add the effects of record-high levels of unemployment and the 52% of auto insurance customers who say they plan to either reduce coverage, shop for another carrier or switch to another carrier because of COVID-19, and the outcome for the industry is clear: price is going to be a bigger factor. Direct insurers are in the best position right now to benefit from this trend due to their cost-of-acquisition advantages, but there’s more to acquiring – and retaining – customers than price alone. Customers who have a poor experience are eight times more likely to shop than those who do not, and brand perception remains critical.

- Tom Super, head of property and casualty insurance at J.D. Power.


Read more: PROGRESSIVE TO OFFER $1 BILLION IN REBATES TO AUTO INSURANCE CUSTOMERS


Other key findings of J.D. Power’s 2020 Insurance Shopping Study included:

  • There is little loyalty in the auto insurance market.

Prior to the COVID-19 outbreak, 77% of auto insurance customers were either actively shopping or experienced an adverse event – like poor customer service or a rate increase �� that triggered shopping. According to a J.D. Power survey conducted on April 14 – in the midst of the coronavirus outbreak – 52% of auto insurance customers said they planned to manage insurance costs by either reducing coverage, shopping for another carrier or switching carriers because of COVID-19.

  • Price continues to grow as a factor in customer satisfaction.

Price continues to grow as a factor in customer satisfaction. Since 2012, the price factor measured by J.D. Power’s study has increased by 54% as a key driver of satisfaction with the purchase experience. At the same time, the gap between overall satisfaction and price satisfaction has grown. Over the past decade, customers have generally become more satisfied with their insurers – in all areas except price.

  • Direct models are resonating with customers.

Direct carriers have several structural advantages that help them click with customers, according to J.D. Power. Lower commissions and administrative expenses give direct carriers a 10-percentage-point cost advantage over exclusive and independent agent carriers. Ninety per cent (90%) of customers say they are open to purchasing auto insurance online. Direct carriers have taken seven percentage points of market share from agent insurers over the past decade, and this year earned the highest scores in every factor of the purchase experience in J.D. Power’s study.

  • Poor customer experience destroys brand loyalty.

According to J.D. Power, the primary drivers that push customers to shop around are poor service experiences and price. Customers who are frustrated over price are five times more likely to shop around than those who aren’t. Customers who experience poor service are eight times more likely to shop.

GEICO ranked the highest among large auto insurers for providing a satisfying purchase experience, with a score of 867 out of a possible 1,000. Nationwide (862) ranked second, with State Farm (860) rounding out the top three.
 

Read more: TEXAS FARM BUREAU INSURANCE TO REFUND OVER $20 MILLION TO AUTO INSURANCE CUSTOMERS


The Hartford ranked the highest among mid-sized auto insurers with a score of 895. Erie Insurance ranked second with a score of 880 and American Family ranked third with a score of 878.
 

About GEICO

Government Employees Insurance Company. Puzzled, are you? Well, the name goes back to the beginnings of our company. Founder Leo Goodwin first targeted a customer base of U.S. government employees and military personnel. Today, of course, GEICO has grown to provide insurance to a wide range of customers. GEICO is built on ingenuity, perseverance, innovation, resilience, and hard, honest work. From its humble beginnings in the midst of the Great Depression to its current place as one of the most successful companies in the nation, GEICO represents a quintessential American success story.
 

About Progressive

For more than 80 years, Progressive has offered a wide range of insurance choices to customers, including Auto, Home, Renters, Commercial Auto, Small Business, Motorcycle, Boat policies, and more. Progressive is the third largest auto insurer in the country a combined effort of every single Progressive person. We’re a diverse group of more than 36,000 talented employees—from all walks of life, all fields of business, and all 50 states. Everyone here plays a role in our success as we continue to find new and better ways to move the insurance industry forward and be there for our customers during every stage of their lives.

Spotlight

Spotlight

Related News

Core Insurance

Inszone Insurance Services Continues Expansion in Colorado with the Acquisition of High Desert Insurance

Business Wire | January 29, 2024

Inszone Insurance Services, a rapidly growing national provider of commercial, personal, and benefits insurance, is pleased to announce its recent acquisition of High Desert Insurance, out of Pueblo, Colorado. High Desert Insurance, born in 2011, has been a trusted insurance go-to for over ten years. Starting with three employees, they've grown into a team of seven, always coming through with top-notch insurance solutions for individuals and businesses. The values of High Desert Insurance mesh perfectly with what Inszone Insurance is all about, making this acquisition a great fit as Inszone looks to grow its services in Colorado. "We are delighted to welcome High Desert Insurance to the Inszone family," expressed Chris Walters, CEO of Inszone Insurance Services. "With a decade-long track record of delivering outstanding outcomes for its clients, High Desert Insurance has built a commendable legacy. Our commitment extends to preserving and enhancing this legacy by offering comprehensive back-office support and access to additional markets to the High Desert team." The newly acquired High Desert Insurance will operate under the Inszone Insurance brand and maintain its existing Pueblo, Colorado, location, ensuring a seamless transition and consistency in service for its valued clients. Inszone Insurance is dedicated to retaining the experienced team from High Desert Insurance to ensure the continuation of the high-quality service that clients have come to expect. As Inszone Insurance continues its strategic growth, the acquisition of High Desert Insurance represents not only a significant expansion but also a blending of values, reinforcing the commitment to excellence in service within the dynamic landscape of Colorado. Founded in 2002 and headquartered in Sacramento, California, Inszone is a full-service insurance brokerage firm that provides a broad array of property & casualty insurance and employee benefits solutions. With a strong, experienced management team, Inszone continues to grow organically and through acquisitions. With 54 locations across California, Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Illinois, Kansas, Michigan, Missouri, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Texas, Utah, and Washington, the company is looking to expand further throughout the United States.

Read More

Claims, Life Insurance

Genpact Works with AWS and Amazon Business to Redefine Insurance Claims Lifecycle

Genpact | November 30, 2023

Genpact a global professional services firm focused on delivering outcomes that transform businesses, announced it is working with Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Amazon Business to introduce a transformed approach to property loss replacement and claims management. Genpact is leveraging its extensive claims management expertise as well as Amazon Bedrock generative AI capabilities and Amazon Business procurement API integrations, including pricing information, to reduce the claims submission process from weeks to days. This initiative is streamlining replacement item identification and enabling more efficient and timely delivery of policyholder estimates. Amazon Bedrock is a fully managed service that provides access to foundation models (FMs) from leading AI companies through an application programming interface (API) to build and scale generative AI applications. "AI is fundamentally reshaping the landscape of the insurance industry," said Sameer Dewan, Global Operating Officer, Genpact. Our Genpact AI-driven automated pricing workflow, powered by AWS, is transforming the research, significantly reducing the time adjusters spend investigating by as much as 75 percent. By automating routine tasks and enhancing decision making, our AI solution is empowering smarter pricing decisions, expediting claims settlements, and bringing about a profound transformation in the customer experience. [Source - PR Newswire] Genpact is committed to delivering measurable value to its clients through ongoing innovation. In the future, the company plans to integrate additional AI services into the automated workflow to introduce enhanced features. These include real-time summaries of market values for claimed contents and optimal action recommendations for further processing. About Genpact Genpact is a global professional services firm delivering the outcomes that transform our clients' businesses and shape their future. We're guided by our real-world experience redesigning and running thousands of processes for hundreds of global companies. Our clients – including many in the Global Fortune 500 – partner with us for our unique ability to combine deep industry and functional expertise, leading talent, and proven methodologies to drive collaborative innovation that turns insights into action and delivers outcomes at scale. We create lasting competitive advantages for our clients and their customers, running digitally enabled operations and applying our Data-Tech-AI services to design, build, and transform their businesses. And we do it all with purpose. From New York to New Delhi and more than 30 countries in between, our 115,000+ team is passionate in its relentless pursuit of a world that works better for people.

Read More

Insurance Technology

Integrity and Hemati Insurance Agency Join Forces to Strengthen Expansive Services for Agents

Integrity Marketing Group, LLC | December 05, 2023

Integrity Marketing Group, LLC a leading distributor of life and health insurance, and provider of wealth management and retirement planning solutions, today announced it has partnered with Hemati Insurance Agency, an independent marketing organization based in Austin, Texas, and led by Eric Hemati. Financial details of the partnership were not disclosed. "Eric comes to Integrity with two decades of experience and a deep understanding of this business, but he knew there would be more opportunities for growth through our partnership — he wanted to help even more people and offer the strongest support and products possible to his agents," explained Bryan W. Adams, Co-Founder and CEO of Integrity. "We created Integrity precisely to give leaders, like Eric, the meaningful foundation and cutting-edge resources they need to take an agency to the next level. Now that Hemati Insurance Agency is partnered with Integrity, it can tap into an amazing network of expertise and experience. Our partners are positioned to help one another expand and thrive, which stems from our philosophy that a rising tide lifts all boats. I can't wait to see the 'Integrity Effect' of powerful growth make an impact on Hemati Insurance Agency — this business will be one to watch!" After spending several years in the field, Hemati brought a valuable agent perspective when founding Hemati Insurance Agency in 2003. The company provides clients across the country with life and health insurance products. In order to help protect more families, Hemati focuses on optimizing the agent experience by constantly expanding its support, mentorship and technology offerings. This commitment led to a partnership with Integrity. "Integrity is a force multiplier! Its vision of bringing together world-class services, technology and leaders to elevate agents' potential is an approach I resonated with immediately," shared Eric Hemati, Principal of Hemati Insurance Agency. Integrity has also created the dream team of partners in the insurance space — these are the leading players in the industry who have founded some of the country's most successful agencies. The opportunity to tap into their wisdom and collective experience is a game-changer for any entrepreneur. My agents are thrilled to utilize Integrity's best-in-class products, especially LeadCENTER and MedicareCENTER, which take the guesswork out of prospecting and allow us to help more people faster and more efficiently. This partnership is a major milestone for our business and significantly accelerates our growth. With Integrity's support, our future looks exceptionally promising. [Source -PR Newswire] By developing thoughtful solutions and best-in-class products, Integrity offers resources that make an agent's job more effective and fulfilling. Its end-to-end insurtech platform offers proprietary access to groundbreaking products such as Ask Integrity, a revolutionary AI-powered and voice-activated customer relationship management technology, and LeadCENTER, an on-demand platform which instantly connects qualified leads anywhere in the country with agents ready to serve. Integrity partners receive additional world-class resources and support, including strategic leadership guidance, richly insightful data and analytics, and ongoing product innovation to keep agents at the forefront of industry developments. Integrity empowers agents to reach more families through its holistic approach to life, health and wealth solutions. The Integrity partner network, comprised of many of the country's leading insurance and financial services companies, recognizes the growing need for cross-industry initiatives to offer comprehensive planning and services to every consumer. This prestigious group is collaborating on best practices and innovations that benefit all stakeholders. Their ingenuity and commitment help more Americans plan for the good days ahead. About Integrity Integrity, headquartered in Dallas, Texas, is a leading distributor of life and health insurance, and provider of innovative solutions for wealth management and retirement planning. Through its broad partner network of agents and advisors, Integrity helps millions of Americans protect their life, health and wealth with a commitment to meet them wherever they are — in person, over the phone and online. Integrity's proprietary, cutting-edge technology helps expand the insurance and financial planning experience for all stakeholders using an omnichannel approach. In addition, Integrity develops products with carrier partners and markets them compliantly through its nationwide distribution network. Providing best-in-class service to our clients and consumers is at the center of Integrity's holistic approach to life, health and wealth protection. The company and its partners focus on helping families and individuals prepare for the good days ahead, so they can make the most of what life brings. About Hemati Insurance Agency Hemati Insurance Agency has rapidly become a key and influential player in the insurance industry. The Austin, Texas-based agency focuses on empowering its agents, thereby ensuring the best possible service for its clients. Hemati Insurance Agency consistently provides in-depth training, resources and support designed to help its team of hundreds of agents work more efficiently and effectively. It is also committed to delivering a wide range of personalized solutions that help protect more than 20,000 American families annually.

Read More